How much do water heater repair services typically cost?
- Jamaica, New York Average$679
- Typical Range$284 - $900
- Low End - High End$125 - $1,750

Residential and Commercial Water heater install
"It was an absolute joy and delight working with Tarique and Andrew. My initial conversation with Tarique was very professional and informative. He put me at ease and i felt comfortable asking questions about the project throughout. I really appreciated that we could coordinate and send pics of the issues beforehand so there would be no surprises at the time the work started. His quote was reasonable, not the cheapest option but the last time i went for the cheaper option I got stuck with a plumber who triggered my PTSD. Tarique and Andrew were both very respectful, professional and completed the job in the time allotted and i appreciate that. I have a very short list of people i will call back again to work on our family home and Caprens Piping & Heating is one of those businesses that will be visiting us again (the number's on the fridge). Thanks guys!"
5E06CC1C78E8BAE241F4ECDAEA11E8329AD678AEA1D82B94A6795E11218411B9 5. in December 2025

Plumbing
"On 11/9/22, I contacted Ilia to replace my defective A O Smith Water Heater and wanted the same brand. He provided a fair price and realistic timeframe without any haggling. A few hours after the call, my new water heater was up and running, and the old one was taken away. I&A Piping was the best contractor we dealt with while others were looking to charge higher depending on the timeline and if it was an emergency. I highly recommend them and will use them in the future for other work."
Amit P. in November 2022

Plumbing repairs and install, **Over 20 Years Experience**, **Over 21 Years Experience** , and 5 more
"Quick to respond and was able to fix my problem that same day."
Marlene B. in December 2024
Plumbing, Heating
"I can't say enough good things about Jimmy- He responded to an emergency sewer backup & when he was here he advised me of the urgent need to replace a VERY old basement slop sink with rotting plumbing (I didn't even realize it) He installed the new sink, reorganized the piping, installed new cutoff valves, changed a bunch of other hoses,etc. He is prompt, courteous, neat & reasonable. What a guy!!!"
Ronnie K. in December 2018
Plumbing, Heating
"Niko was a professional, he explained and diagnosed the situation. We needed radiator repair and he was upfront and clear about the cost. He completed the work in a short period of time . With his amiable and professional demeanor I feel comfortable recommending his services."
FF7D71C60235E8AF31B610547FC3834C01E80619A8AD769B3633BD383826818D C. in December 2025

Plumbing
"Above and beyond service. Very kind and professional. I would recommend."
Tina M. in October 2023

Furnace Installs and Repairs, Central Air Conditioning Installs and repairs, Boiler Installs and Repairs , and 1 more
"Very respectful and polite service, explained every process well and thoroughly."
Camits P. in December 2023
sump pump install/repair, Plumbing, fixtures , and 2 more
"Service was prompt, effective (20 years of clogged hair, far away the pipe), and reasonably priced. The plumber, Alfons, was polite and professional. I would definitely recommend him to those in need of a plumber."
Elizabeth O. in September 2018
Jamaica Plumbers are rated 4.6 out of 5 based on 904 reviews of 904 pros.
The HomeAdvisor Community Rating is an overall rating based on verified reviews and feedback from our community of homeowners that have been connected with service professionals. See individual business pages for full, detailed reviews.
What kind of water heater do you want repaired?
What is the problem with your water heater?
What is the heat source for the water heater?
What kind of location is this?
Find out how HomeAdvisor can help your business