How much do water heater repair services typically cost?
- Bay Shore, New York Average$679
- Typical Range$200 - $679
- Low End - High End$125 - $1,750
Plumbing
"Joe was prompt and came to check the issue on the same day I called . He did a neat job replacing our water boiler for a fair price. He was very professional and easy to work with. He also followed up on the job to ensure we had hot water. I would highly recommend him."
KRUPA D. in October 2024

Swimming Pools, Renovations, Swimming Pools , and 1 more
"Clinton made himself available within 2 hours and was able to diagnose and solve the problem very quickly."
tom P. in August 2018
HVAC, Furnaces, Boilers , water heaters , central A/C , and 1 more
"Excellent service; professional"
Wayne H. in June 2019

"This team installed an oil fired boiler last month. I didn't want to give a review until our oil company said it passed their inspection which it did. They came promptly. It took all day to install. They got it working. We did have a hiccup but they came and took care of it. I was nervous to use them but so glad we chose them. Roberto and his team were great. They know their stuff. So yes I highly recommend them. See the old and new."
8B936264D589D2583DC3785FEC6217B1A48E4BE587E99459624F1DDA1D750CA2 3. in December 2025

Plumbing repairs and install, **Over 20 Years Experience**, **Over 21 Years Experience** , and 5 more
"Quick to respond and was able to fix my problem that same day."
Marlene B. in December 2024
Plumbing
"Andre is very knowledgeable about the job. He not only fix the problem but also advise the necessary preventative action."
Victor P. in April 2024
Heat Pump - Repair or Service, Gas Furnace: Repair, Electric Furnace: Repair , and 6 more
"Phil is trustworthy - explained my furnace problem in laymen's terms, was very clear on my options and the associated costs. Was very timely and called to keep me posted on his whereabouts when stepping out to purchase a part. He guaranteed his work and going forward, I know Phil is the person to call for my future heating requirements and I would recommend him to others who are considering heating repair/service. Thank you very much Phil! Very satisfied customer in Baldwin!"
Evelyn G. in December 2018

In business since 1985
Commercial / Residential Heating Repair and Install, Central Humidification Systems, Central Air Conditioning , and 2 more
About us: "We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumers needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job."
Bay Shore Plumbers are rated 4.7 out of 5 based on 309 reviews of 309 pros.
The HomeAdvisor Community Rating is an overall rating based on verified reviews and feedback from our community of homeowners that have been connected with service professionals. See individual business pages for full, detailed reviews.
What kind of water heater do you want repaired?
What is the problem with your water heater?
What is the heat source for the water heater?
What kind of location is this?
Find out how HomeAdvisor can help your business