Compare Quotes from Painting Contractors
Get Quotes Now

Painting Contractors in Bay Shore, NY

Find local pros

How It Works

  1. Answer a few questions about your home project.
  2. Within seconds, get matched with top-rated local pros.
  3. Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Service Pros

    BN

    In business since 2021

    Bay Shore, NY·

    small handyman projects, interior and exterior painting, powerwashing

    About us: "At Brand New Home Improvement we pride ourselves on being the best home improvement company in the area. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. Being a screened and approved professional gives you the peace of mind you need to allow us to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started!"

    MP
    jericho, NY·

    "My paint job is complete and Kenny's team did a great job. He is a great owner and stayed on top of my project. My painters, Guillermo and Jose were professional and thorough, and very patient with me, and my stress issues during this project.!! I would highly recommend Metropolitan for any renovations needed."

    Kim G. in June 2016

    GM&J Painting Logo
    West Babylon, NY·

    Painting

    "This company and owner Rene are incredible. He’s completed several jobs for me and couldn’t be happier. He is fast, neat, communicative, and very reasonably priced. Highly highly recommend"

    A G. in October 2021

    Diamond Hands Painting LTD Logo
    Selden, NY·

    Cabinet restoration, Painting, Interior prep/painting , and 6 more

    "Chris and his crew refinished my cabinets, countertops and backsplash. My dream kitchen has come true thanks to Diamond Hands Painting!!"

    25BF53BD830A36A42EB99BF585D4FE5620104ECCBF6643FD8A58707976C4D348 8. in September 2025

    Decor Wallpaper Logo
    Roselle, NJ·

    Wallpaper

    "Alex did A Fantastic Job Installing wallpaper in our New Bar! Highly reccomended!!!"

    Matt M. in November 2021

    Blessed Remodeling Logo
    Nesconset, NY·

    Bathroom - Remodel, Interior Trim and Decorative Moldings - Install, Additions and Remodels , and 6 more

    "Exceptionally pleased with Jorge and his crew who rate five stars @@@@@â ¦. Jorge was friendly and communicated often throughout the project to ensure that we were pleased with the quality of workmanshipâ ¦ I would definitely recommend him to anyone who is looking for projects to be done timely with qualityâ ¦ We will definitely use him again in the future for any needed projects or repairsâ ¦"

    Patricia W. in October 2022

    TO
    Manorville, NY·

    Home improvements. Kitchens, baths, etc., Total rehabbing of homes., Interior painting

    "Very professional and courteous. Pays attention to detail and does not rush the work. Great quality painting and service."

    Alfonso G. in July 2021

    Level Up Custom Renovations and Efficiency Logo
    Deer Park, NY·

    Custom builds, Refinishing, Remodeling , and 1 more

    "What a terrific crew. Nick was exceptional with his explanations of what and how the process was going to happen. He always answered my phone calls and gave me 100% reassurance throughout the process. The work him and his crew did was absolutely incredible. They made my kitchen look like a $250k for a fraction of the cost. My bathroom was completely renovated and everything just looks so amazing. I know exactly who to call for my next project. I highly recommend him and his crew for any and all kinds of work. Plumbing, Electrical, Carpentry, Painting... These guys did it all! 10 Stars if I could!"

    Tony B. in March 2022

    CW
    Valley Stream, NY·

    Interior Home Painting, Exterior Home Painting

    "Very professional. Very meticulous. Our house looked so festive. Pricing very fair. Will use them again next year. Just hired them to paint the complete inside of my house."

    67641A37CE5A6F0177FAEED93AD5F7BDA2157C84E985728187A667B79A609659 2. in March 2025

    MM

    In business since 2020

    Lawn maintenance and care, Fence installation, Fence repair

    About us: "We are a locally owned and operated company with decades of experience, We value honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. We offer a variety of Home Improvement services that are customizable to each individual project & specialize in handyman/carpentry work, window and door installation, and a variety of other projects. We pride ourselves on the quality of our work as well as our commitment to outstanding results."

    HR
    Bay Shore, NY·

    Electrical, Home improvement

    "Luis is a class act. Extremely knowledgeable and a hard worker. He will definitely do more work for me in the future."

    Leroy G. in October 2021

    HM Construction Group, Inc. (Long Island Handyman Group) Logo
    Plainview, NY·

    Sheetrock, Trim, Bathrooms, Finishes, Handyman Services, All Phases of Construction , and 12 more

    "Moises and Edward and the crew did a repair of my facia. They told me to get PVC so it would last longer. They also repaired cracked walls and ceiling and painted. They did perfect work. Did so good I kept finding more work for them because it looked so good. They are so polite and respectful and right on time. Also they are very fair with their prices and don't push for or more work. I now consider them friends. Don't waste you're time because you won't beat their prices. They can do anything too. Bathroom, kitchen, floors. I will hire them again they are the best."

    Dan P. in August 2019

    Razaline Builders Inc Logo
    Brooklyn, NY·

    Concrete & Masonry, Painting/Lath and Plaster, Flooring( Wood, vinyl, tile e.tc) , and 3 more

    "Always on time and within budget"

    Yasmeen L. in March 2017

    PP
    Hauppauge, NY·

    Interior Painting or Staining: 5 + Rooms, Interior Surfaces - Paint or Stain - For Business, Exterior Building - Paint or Stain - For Business , and 14 more

    "This was a very professional company. We hired them to repaint and refinish our kitchen cabinets. The crew did a fantastic job!. Every day there was a supervisor to check on the status of the job and to keep us updated. The crew was very clean and protected the surrounding walls and floors. The other areas of the house were taped off from the kitchen to prevent any dust from spreading. They worked hard and did a professional job! Would rehire them in a heartbeat. You will not be disappointed."

    Carly D. in December 2016

    F5 Construction Services Logo
    Mckees Rocks, PA·

    Plumbing, Carpentry, Doors , and 6 more

    "Working with Werley Home Improvements was a wonderful experience. They responded quickly, did an excellent job in a very short amount of time, and offered great solutions to additional problems discovered during construction with a very reasonable rate. We could not be more pleased with the finished result, and absolutely recommend this business and will be keeping their info for future jobs. Jim and his team went above and beyond to make our porches beautiful and sturdy for decades to come. They were respectful of our property and time, and made the whole experience painless, which for our first major construction job as homeowners was a relief and a blessing. Definitely recommended!!!"

    Glenna S. in October 2021

    BD
    Nesconset, NY·

    Murals and Custom Painting, Interior Painting

    "I recently hired Brianna to paint the interior of my house, and I couldn't be more pleased with the results. Brianna was not only reliable but also a pleasure to work with. Her professionalism and attention to detail were evident throughout the entire process. The quality of her work truly reflected the value for the money spent. I highly recommend Brianna for anyone seeking a skilled and reliable painter for their home."

    Samantha S. in January 2024

    EI

    In business since 2006

    About us: "At Eyeris Industries LTD, we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We strongly believe in giving our absolute best in all the work we perform. We are experts, and will always keep you educated about the work process. We look forward to earning your business!"

    Best Way Roofing & Chimney Logo
    manorville, NY·

    "We have been having a problem with pigeons hanging around all day on/under our solar panels. I originally had a handyman who was going to install mesh around the edges of the panels and yesterday (the day he was supposed to come) found out he didn't have insurance/license so I canceled. I then went into a Zoom meeting and heard the darn pigeons cooing and fluttering all over the roof and got so upset. I came to Angi and found Best Choice Roofing (aka Best Way) - he called me back right away and in less than an hour he was here. The first thing he did was hand me his business card with his License # on it. Very professional. He got up on the roof, then in a few minutes came down and gave me an estimate. Once I accepted, he called his team to assist and he started on the roof. They were super clean - blew out my gutters, blew everything out from under the solar panels, and made sure to blow the porch and front of my house to remove any debris. I had peace of mind that they were licensed and insured. Today I am happy to announce, I have not heard ONE PIGEON! I know this company usually does more like roofing and gutter-type projects, but I will be letting any of my neighbors with solar panels/pigeons know who to call. Great crew. Thanks so much!"

    Riesa F. in April 2023

    Carlos Home Improvement Logo

    In business since 2010

    Deer Park, NY·

    Roofs, Siding, Bathrooms , and 2 more

    About us: "We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumerÂ’s needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job."

    Pro Master Construction, Inc. Logo
    Shirley, NY·

    Roofing, Gutters, Deck , and 4 more

    "We really lucked out when we hired Luan to replace our deck. He is professional, punctual and hard-working. Luan was very open about pricing and the amount he quoted was the amount he billed. We had this old, neglected screened-in porch that I couldn't wait to get rid of. Luan tore down our old porch and helped us create the deck of our dreams. We are SO happy with our deck now that we spend a lot more time in our yard. We can't wait to hire him to do more projects around our home! Hire him. You will not regret it."

    Zhaleh S. in May 2022

    IG

    In business since 2022

    About us: "INNOVATION GENERAL CONSTRUCTION is dedicated to providing our customers with the best quality and craftsmanship. We are here to build relationships with our customers and communities and to provide our employees with a great place to work. We look forward to working with you."

    GP
    Stroudsburg, PA·

    Mansions ALL INTERIOR REPAIR WORK AND EXTERIOR REPAIR., Churches ALL REPAIRS INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR PLASTER REPAIR .PAINTING., Specialize in HISTORICAL RESTORATIONS , , and 2 more

    "It is with deep satisfaction that I recommend Gradys Painting and Plastering & Construction. Mr. George Grady is a skilled craftsman. He was hired to correct long neglected and extensive masonry and window issues on a large, beautiful Presbyterian Church built in the Civil War era in Philadelphia. The property was neglected with only minimal maintenance performed over the last 40+ years. The building was in severe decline and in need of stabilization and restoration on many fronts. Cracked ledge plates were chipped out and reestablished, internal walls damaged by leakage were broken out and repaired, brickwork was repointed and in severe cases reestablished to original strength and beauty. Leaks around the base of the building were addressed to stabilize deterioration of the foundation. Large rotted window sills under beautiful stained glass windows were restored after significant masonry reestablishment due to water damage under the rotted out sills. Broken and missing stained glass windows are in the process of repair and replacement. The process started with new metal frames cast by Mr. Grady. The new frames will hold clear painted replications of the original stained glass, also crafted by Mr. Grady. Regular windows all around the church and manse were also repaired and restored. Roof leaks were accurately identified and repaired. A sagging plaster ceiling has been torn out and restored. All this work was done by Mr. Grady alone or with an occasional helper. He worked with care, expertise and respect for the original structure. The results far exceeded our expectations and have injected new life into a building on the brink. This building, owned by the Presbytery of Philadelphia, now houses a new urban ministry in a newly gentrifying area of the city. We are happy to have had the good fortune to be connected to Gradys Painting and Plastering & Construction by Service Magic."

    Pilling C. in December 2010

    Glare by JTO, LLC Logo

    In business since 2022

    Far Rockaway, NY·

    Interior and Exterior Painting

    About us: "I've lived in New York since I was a child, I started this company because I wanted to be my own boss and build my own future. I am easygoing, I like to have fun with the process!. I most want my customers to know I take quality seriously, you won't find a better provider."

Showing 1-23 of 23 results

Frequently asked questions

Painters usually price a job by the square feet of the project. Sometimes they’ll include flat fees for fixed expenses, like overhead and permits.

We make finding a painter easy. Simple use our directory to find a painter. Here you can browse local pros, check their reviews and do your first screening without ever having to call. We’ve also prescreened all the pros for you, to give you peace of mind.

Interior painting makes for a doable DIY project. You can save some money and get a real sense of accomplishment by doing this yourself. And, with the right prep work – covering, taping and scraping – it’s fairly forgiving. But it takes a lot of time to move furniture, tape trim, prep the surface and cover your floor, let alone apply the actual paint. Instead, save yourself the time and hassle and find a local interior painter.

Leave exterior painting to the pros. Not only do you need to worry about the type and quality of the paint, you’ll also likely need a ladder and considerably more prep work. You’ll likely need additional equipment like ladders, scaffolding and possibly a paint sprayer. It’s almost cheaper to just hire a pro. Talk to a local exterior house painter about your project.

  1. Do your research. Understand what to expect and what to look for in a pro. Look at paint types, prices and costs.
    1. Interior home painting costs $1,000-$2,800
    2. Exterior painting costs $1,700-$4,100
    3. Painting a ceiling costs $150-$350
    4. Painting cabinets costs $350-$1,200
    5. Trim painting costs $500-$1,500
    6. Calculate paint coverage
  2. Call pros for site inspections and estimates. Always get three to five estimates.
  3. Check references, compare quotes, look at past work. After you have estimates in hand, do one final pass to compare the contractors.
  4. Sign a contract with the pro of your choice. You might need to make a down payment, usually 25% to 50% of the total project cost to cover material costs, but not all pros require this. Don’t pay for the entire project upfront.

  • A complete inspection. Each pro takes a walk around your home to evaluate the condition of your current paint, the size of the job and any obstacles for accessing the site. They do this to see how much prep work they’ll need and estimate how long the job will take. The more thorough the inspection, the more accurate the quote.
  • Color consultation. Expect each contractor to have varying color options and suggestions. However, you have the final say.
  • Listen to the pro – they’re experts after all – but don’t get pushed into a color combination or finish type that you don’t want. Understand the different exterior paints or interior paint choices before your pro arrives.
  • A rough estimate or complete quote. Finishing contractors vary here. Usually, they can quote straightforward projects on the spot. But some may need to take it back to their shop to run numbers and give you a detailed estimate with costs broken out. Neither method is better than the other, but just make sure to get multiple quotes.

  1. How long have you been in business? A long business history helps you avoid shoddy companies. It’s hard for a service business to stay in business if they don’t do good work.
  2. Are you licensed and insured? Not all states require a license for painting homes, but many do. Always use one that’s insured.
  3. Do you belong to any professional organizations? You’ll find many online, like the Painting Contractors Association or the Finishing Contractors Association?
  4. Do you have other work I can look at? Always check a portfolio or, in the case of painters, it’s better to look at work they did a few years ago to see how well it’s held up.
  5. How long will the job take? Get a rough estimate but get it in writing.
  6. How many people are in your crew? This is especially important if you work remotely. More people generally means more noise, but they’ll be done faster.
  7. Will I be in the way if I’m home during the painting? You usually won’t be in the way, but this question helps you understand what to expect while they’re working. They’ll need to lay down coverings and do a lot of prep work.
  8. Do you guarantee your work? Never hire a painter who doesn’t guarantee their work. This often means they’ll rush the prep work, since peeling never happens right away.
  9. What type of paint do you use, and how long is it rated to last? Different rooms need different paint and the exterior needs exterior paint. It comes in different grades with different guaranteed lifetimes.
  10. Can you supply a written estimate and contract? Never use a painter who isn’t willing to put his work in writing.

Top Painting Projects

HomeAdvisor Community Rating

Overall Rating:

Bay Shore Painting Contractors are rated 4.9 out of 5 based on 1230 reviews of 1230 pros.

The HomeAdvisor Community Rating is an overall rating based on verified reviews and feedback from our community of homeowners that have been connected with service professionals. See individual business pages for full, detailed reviews.


Other Top Projects in Your Area

Other Cities in New York

If you're looking for Painting Contractors that serve a different city in New York, here are some popular suggestions:

Find additional New York Painting Contractors

Find Painting Pros in Bay Shore, NY

HomeAdvisor: The nation's largest network of screened and rated pros.

Tell us about your project and we'll match you to the perfect pros.

Get Matched With Pros

Find Pros Nearby

Do you provide these professional services?

Find out how HomeAdvisor can help your business

See Local Demand

See Recent Leads

Recent Job Requests for Painting Contractors in Bay Shore, NY

  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 02/02/24
    Location: Home/Residence
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 1 - 2 rooms
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    Comment: I have two Bathrooms and a spare room I want to have painted
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/29/24
    Location: Home/Residence
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 3 - 4 rooms
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/20/24
    Desired Completion Date: More than 2 weeks
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    Check off each feature that will need to be painted/stained. (Check all that apply).: Interior door(s)
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Trim
    Request Stage: Ready to Hire
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/20/24
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    Location: Home/Residence
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Trim
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 1 - 2 rooms
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/20/24
    Desired Completion Date: Within 2 weeks
    Request Stage: Ready to Hire
    Check off each feature that will need to be painted/stained. (Check all that apply).: Interior door(s)
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Trim
    Comment: I need the job
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/18/24
    Request Stage: Planning & Budgeting
    Desired Completion Date: Within 2 weeks
    What do you want to paint?: Other
    Surface Material: Other / I don't know
    Square Footage: 1500-3000 sqft
    Comment: I would like to get an estimate for Paint or Stain Exterior Surfaces
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/18/24
    Location: Home/Residence
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 3 - 4 rooms
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    Comment: Well, I want to continue growing in painting since that is the type of work that I like.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/18/24
    Location: Home/Residence
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 3 - 4 rooms
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Trim
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/18/24
    Location: Home/Residence
    How many rooms do you want to paint?: 3 - 4 rooms
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Ceiling
    What needs to be painted? (Check all that apply): Wall
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/15/24
    Request Stage: Ready to Hire
    Desired Completion Date: Within 2 weeks
    What do you want to paint?: Less than half of the home exterior (1-2 sides)
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/14/24
    Desired Completion Date: Timing is flexible
    Request Stage: Planning & Budgeting
    Location: Home/Residence
    Comment: Desk
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/11/24
    Desired Completion Date: More than 2 weeks
    Request Stage: Ready to Hire
    What do you want to paint?: The exterior trim
    What do you want to paint?: A deck or porch
    Comment: Customer did not provide additional comments. Please contact the customer to discuss the details of this project.
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/08/24
    Desired Completion Date: Timing is flexible
    Request Stage: Planning & Budgeting
    Historical Work: No
    House Occupancy: Furnished and occupied
    Location: Home/Residence
    Rooms to be Painted: Living areas
    Painting Needs:: Walls and ceilings
    Number of Rooms: 2
  • Project Location: Bay Shore, NY
    Date: 01/07/24
    Desired Completion Date: Timing is flexible
    Request Stage: Planning & Budgeting
    Historical Work: No
    House Occupancy: Furnished and occupied
    Location: Home/Residence
    Rooms to be Painted: Living areas
    Painting Needs:: Walls and ceilings
    Number of Rooms: 2

References Available
Tell us your zip code to view pricing & schedule
Tell us your location to view pricing & schedule
Choose your project to view pricing & schedule

Please enter valid zip.

Please choose a location.

We're sorry but the time you have chosen is no longer available.
Please select a new time below:
does not provide service to View pros who serve this zip
Enter a zip code to view which pros serve this zip.
There was an issue connecting to the server. Please try again or call Customer Service at 1-888-811-ANGI.
We're sorry but the time you have chosen is no longer available.
Please select a new time below:

Select your appointment type and time:

Final Step - Confirm Your Appointment:

Confirm your appointment with on , - Change


Required
Required
Required
Required
 
 
 

By clicking Confirm Appointment, you affirm you have read and agree to the HomeAdvisor Terms & Conditions, and you agree and authorize HomeAdvisor and its affiliates, and their networks of Service Professionals, to deliver marketing calls or texts using automated technology to the number you provided above regarding your project and other home services offers. Consent is not a condition of purchase.